Fifty years after Louis Feuillade made his classic Fantômas
series, the infamous master criminal returned to French cinema in this colourful
action comedy, the first of three new Fantômas films to feature Louis de Funès
and Jean Marais. The production team were wary about treading over old ground, so
rather than attempt a straightforward remake of the Feuillade films, they embarked on
a totally different course. With its action-comedy format, the film is far nearer
to being a parody of the popular novels by Marcel Allain et Pierre Souvestre, rather than
a faithful adaptation, which is what Feuillade attempted.
(1964) is certainly a very different film to Fantômas
although both were targeted at mass cinema audiences. Whereas Feuillade's
film is a chilling and atmospheric work which succeeds in conveying the menace of Fantômas,
André Hunebelle's version is little more than a conventional action comedy
which is far more concerned with trivial comic stunts than characterisation.
Because their approaches are so different, it is difficult, and perhaps unfair, to make
comparisons between the two films. However, few would dispute that Feuillade's
makes the better film.
The casting for the 1964 film is interesting and has been a source of great controversy.
Jean Marais was given top billing in the duel role of Fantômas and the journalist
Fandor. Whilst Marais is clearly perfect in the part of Fantômas, with his
powerful physique and elegant movements, his impact on the film is lessened by his playing
a far weaker character, Fandor. The latter is a conventional action hero which,
at over 50, Marais is too old to play convincingly (although he manages to put in some
remarkable action stunts). Presumably to avoid complicating Marais' two roles,
for the part of Fantômas, his lines would be spoken by another actor, Raymond
In spite of Jean Marais having two starring roles in the film, it is Louis de Funès
who dominates the film, in his role as Juve, Fantômas' mortal enemy.
De Funès' was only given the part after another great comic actor, Bourvil,
had turned it down. At the time, de Funès had just become an overnight star
as a result of his appearance in Jean Girault's comedy Le
Gendarme de Saint-Tropez
(the first of a long-running series of films).
De Funès' appearance in Fantômas cemented his popularity and it was
not long after that he became the most popular actor in France.
It is reported that the working relationship between the two lead actors was not good:
Marais resented Louis de Funès' popularity and made unflattering remarks
about his rival's character. Fortunately, none of this antagonism is visible
in the film.
In addition to these dubious casting decisions, the film is also marred by a rather obvious
attempt to compete with the James Bond films, which were as popular in France at the time
as they were elsewhere. In fact, with their obsession with gadgets, girls and interminable
chase sequences, the three Fantômas films of the 1960s come much closer to sending
up the Sean Connery bond films than anything else. The overall design of the film,
particularly the gaudy sets stuffed with incomprehensible scientific paraphernalia, has
that unmistakable kitsch 1960s feel to it.
When the film was first released in 1964, it wasn't quite the rip-roaring success
its producers were hoping for. However, its audience of two million spectators was more
than enough to guarantee a sequel, which came the following year with Fantômas
The above article was written for filmsdefrance.com and should not be reproduced in any medium without the author's permission.