L'Inconnu de Strasbourg
1998 Drama / Thriller   
 
Credits
  • Director: Valeria Sarmiento
  • Script: Gérard Mordillat, Evelyne Pieiller, Raoul Ruiz, Valeria Sarmiento
  • Photo: Acácio de Almeida
  • Music: Jorge Arriagada
  • Cast: Ornella Muti (Madeleine), Charles Berling (Jean-Paul), Johan Leysen (Bastien), Christian Vadim (Audiard), Laurence Masliah (Magda), Francis Freyburger (Orgel), Jacques Pieiller (Robert), Georges Du Fresne (Allumet), Martin Adamiec (Le peintre), Xavier Boulanger (Le docteur Petra)
  • Country: France
  • Language: French
  • Runtime: 100 min
 
 
 
Summary
Madeleine is spending an evening with her lover, Jean-Paul, when her husband appears unexpectedly.  The latter produces a gun and forces Madeleine to join in a variant of Russian roulette, which he loses.   Having shot dead her husband, Madeleine implores her lover to run away.  During his flight, Jean-Paul gives a lift to a vagrant, who turns against him, knocking him unconscious before crashing his car.  Believing Jean-Paul to have been killed in a car accident, Madeleine allows police inspector Audiard to draw the obvious conclusion that it was he who killed her husband.  The case is closed and Audiard, a novelist in his spare time, is pleased to have found a plot for his next novel.   When he regains consciousness, Jean-Paul has lost his memory.  He is helped by a kind old man (who turns out to be an arsonist), before returning to his hometown of Strasbourg, to keep a date with someone he has forgotten.  Here, a passing woman recognises him as her husband, Christian Vogel, who disappeared three years ago.  Accepting this identification as fact, Jean-Paul allows himself to be manipulated by the Vogel family so that they can claim their vast inheritance.  Later, Madeleine meets Jean-Paul and is surprised when he fails to recognise her.  Little by little, Jean-Paul recalls his past life and starts to make sense of his bizarre present situation…

Review
L’Inconnu de Strasbourg is an unusual psychological thriller from Chilean director Valeria Sarmiento.   The film initially gives the impression of being a very sloppy genre film, with a plot which relies far too heavily on coincidence to be taken at all seriously.  Then, as the film develops, it becomes a much more unsettling and interesting work, precariously straddling the narrow line between surrealist art and tired cliché, openly recognising its faults and then repeating them, as if this were some kind of bizarre nightmare.

The hand of Raoul Ruiz as co-screenwriter is very apparent – his peculiar brand of dark comedic surrealist fantasy clearly impinging on the low grade B movie thriller plot, giving it an artistic kudos it doesn’t really deserve.  Moody performances from Charles Berling and Ornella Mutti contribute to the film’s weird atmosphere, although the sheer absurdity of the plot (to say nothing of its extraordinary complexity) does ultimately prevent the film from having any real impact.

© James Travers 2004


Write a review for this film...