Germania anno zero (1948)
Directed by Roberto Rossellini

Drama / War
aka: Germany Year Zero

Film Review

Abstract picture representing Germania anno zero (1948)
For the third part of his monumental World War II trilogy, director Roberto Rossellini directs our attention to post-war Berlin and this time shows human suffering from the perspective of the German people.  The film is in the raw neo-realist style of Rossellini's previous films, Open City  (1945) and Paisa (1946) but places greater emphasis on the fictional drama.  This is contrary to Rossellini's statement that the film offers an objective assessment of events.  If anything, the film presents the Germans in a favourable light, as much victims of post-war collapse as the Italians.

Far from being a purely objective work, Germany Year Zero is strikingly humanist, revealing a director who is emotionally deeply engaged with his subject.  This can be seen not just in the narrative, in which the characters are well developed and clearly invite a moral judgement, but also in the director's camera work - close-ups, long shots and ceiling shots showing a constantly shifting perspective which is obviously calculated to stimulate our involvement.   By telling the story from the perspective of a frail young boy, the film cannot fail to be anything other than a subjective view of hardship, fear and guilt.

The film's impact derives largely from its actors' naturalistic performances - particularly that of 12-year old Edmund Koeler, who plays the film's lead character.  Edmund's obvious innocence and vulnerability emphasises the grim plight of those around him he wants to help but is powerless to do so.   In a sense, he is a symbol for the naivety of the German people who, corrupted by Nazi teachings, were driven to commit unspeakable crimes.   In the presence of his former teacher, Herr Enning,  Edmund is totally oblivious to the fact that he is being seduced by evil - he is persuaded of the right to kill because his teacher's gestures have the semblance of friendship.  His innocence prevents him from seeing the sinister, paedophilic side of Enning's caresses.  The guilt which Edmund subsequently feels after having committed his crime makes a bold and simple metaphor for the guilt felt by a nation when the full horror of the Holocaust had been exposed.  In a sense, Germany Year Zero is an ingenious allegory for the German people's corruption by - and subsequent rejection of - Nazism.

It is with its devastating climax that the film drives home its message most forcefully.  Shocking in its brutality and suddenness, it hammers the audience with an unpalatable truth: the ones who would suffer most as a result of the scourge of Nazism would be the German people themselves.   Understandably, it was not a sentiment that the world was prepared to share at the time, and this would account for the film's lukewarm response from the public. Far less successful than Rossellini's previous two films, Germany Year Zero soon fell into obscurity and remained virtually forgotten for decades.

The film clearly meant a great deal to its director, who dedicated it to his young son, who died just before he film was completed.  It is impossible to know for sure the extent of Rossellini's inner torment in making this film, which, by accident or design, ends up with no less an aim than trying to rehabilitate the Germany people in the eyes of an unforgiving world.  The fact that it still has such a strong impact more than half a century on is testament to its director's great personal courage and even greater compassion for his fellow man.

© James Travers 2003
The above content is owned by frenchfilms.org and must not be copied.
Next Roberto Rossellini film:
Saint Francis, God's Jester (1950)

Film Synopsis

In the aftermath of World War II, a devastated Germany struggles to begin afresh.  The plight of 11-year old Edmund is typical of what people all over the country have to endure.  Living in a cramped apartment, he must spend all day trying to find money and food to keep his family from starvation.  Whilst Edmund runs errands and gets involved with black marketers and adolescent crooks, his sister Eva turns to prostitution.  This they must do to feed their bed-ridden father and elder brother, a former Nazi soldier who is hiding from the authorities through fear of arrest.  One day, Edmund meets one of his old school teachers, Herr Enning, who, having lost his job, pimps for child prostitutes.  A disciple of Nazi philosophy, Enning impresses on Edmund the need for the weak to die in order that the strong can prosper.  Later, when his father's illness takes a turn for the worse, Edmund recalls Enning's words and secretly obtains some poison...
© James Travers
The above content is owned by frenchfilms.org and must not be copied.


Film Credits

  • Director: Roberto Rossellini
  • Script: Sergio Amidei, Carlo Lizzani, Roberto Rossellini, Max Kolpé
  • Cinematographer: Robert Juillard
  • Music: Renzo Rossellini
  • Cast: Edmund Moeschke (Edmund), Ernst Pittschau (Il padre), Ingetraud Hinze (Eva), Franz-Otto Krüger (Karl-Heinz), Erich Gühne (Il maestro), Heidi Blänkner (Frau Rademaker), Jo Herbst (Jo), Barbara Hintz (Thilde), Adolf Hitler (Himself), Karl Krüger (Il medico), Alexandra Manys (Amica di Eva), Christl Merker (Christl), Gaby Raak (La donna di generale), Inge Rocklitz (Rifugiata), Hans Sangen (Herr Rademaker), Babsi Schultz-Reckewell (La figlia di Rademacher), Franz von Treuberg (Il generale von Laubniz)
  • Country: Italy
  • Language: German / English / French
  • Support: Black and White
  • Runtime: 78 min
  • Aka: Germany Year Zero

The brighter side of Franz Kafka
sb-img-1
In his letters to his friends and family, Franz Kafka gives us a rich self-portrait that is surprisingly upbeat, nor the angst-ridden soul we might expect.
The best of Russian cinema
sb-img-24
There's far more to Russian movies than the monumental works of Sergei Eisenstein - the wondrous films of Andrei Tarkovsky for one.
The best French Films of the 1910s
sb-img-2
In the 1910s, French cinema led the way with a new industry which actively encouraged innovation. From the serials of Louis Feuillade to the first auteur pieces of Abel Gance, this decade is rich in cinematic marvels.
The greatest French Films of all time
sb-img-4
With so many great films to choose from, it's nigh on impossible to compile a short-list of the best 15 French films of all time - but here's our feeble attempt to do just that.
The Golden Age of French cinema
sb-img-11
Discover the best French films of the 1930s, a decade of cinematic delights...
 

Other things to look at


Copyright © frenchfilms.org 1998-2024
All rights reserved



All content on this page is protected by copyright